Saturday, November 19, 2011

Life in the Solar System - Enceladus

While Voyager 2 was able to provide just low resolution images of Enceladus, stirring up interest, the Cassini mission has revealed that this moon of Saturn is still very active geologically, with geysers shooting water vapors hundreds of miles into the air, similar to the geysers in Yellowstone. Saturn’s gravity creates frictional heat, generating the evaporation of the water ice on Enceladus, creating the geysers. The gases coming through the surface are made of carbon and nitrogen, all sufficient to sustain primitive life. Organic compounds and possibly underground channels of water seem to fulfill the requisites for life. [1] On Earth, microorganisms consuming hydrogen and carbon dioxide, and releasing methane thrive in subsurface volcanic strata where liquid water is present, and take their energy from the planet’s internal heat. Therefore Enceladus seems to be the holy grail of the search for life. [2]

Whether habitable by human understanding or not, exploring only a few celestial bodies in the solar system can forever change human belief about life in the universe. Life could be everywhere, from microorganisms living beneath the surface of Mars and in thermal vents on Enceladus, and creatures developed around other element than carbon that may be living in the methane lakes of Titan, to possibly more complex life forms living in the oceans hidden beneath the surface of Europa. One could be pessimistic and claim that since no life has been seen anywhere else, it is likely that it does not exist. However, the scientists must stay optimistic, as the scientific method requires a hypothesis so that any idea could develop further. Hypothesizing that life may be present on these celestial bodies has at least generated research benefic for the understanding of life’s origin on Earth.

Life may be everywhere, but it is also possible that no evidence of life will turn up. However, if life can come into existence as easily as it seems to have taken shape on Earth, it has to also develop in some other corners of the solar system. Either way, the search for life will provide the ultimate insight into whether life is rare or widespread, and this will be a decisive point in human understanding of the universe.

Notes
[1] Porco, Carolyn. "The Restless World of Enceladus. (Cover story)." Scientific American 299, no. 6 (December 2008): 52-63. Academic Search Premier, EBSCOhost (accessed October 12, 2011), 52.
2 Ibid, 63.

Life in the Solar System - Titan

One step further in the solar system lays Saturn, and its largest moon Titan seems to be one of the most serious candidates for life, however not a carbon based life. While recent images of this moon have revealed a celestial body that looks very much like Earth, the chemical composition of these features is quite different. Titan seems to be more like an early Earth. It has a thick atmosphere, with oceans and mountains, winds, river channels, dunes, as well as weather cycles and volcanism. The atmosphere on Titan is thick, hazy, and similar to Earth’s early atmosphere, composed of 90 percent nitrogen, as well as argon, methane and ethane. No oxygen means there is no water vapor, ozone or carbon dioxide. However there are greenhouse gases: methane and ethane. The methane condenses, forming clouds and methane rain. The lakes on this moon are made of liquid methane. Sunlight converts methane into ethane, generating organic compound. But it is cold on Titan: -180°C, and the atmospheric pressure on the surface is 50 percent greater than on Earth. [1] Titan is the only moon other than Earth’s to have been explored. In January 2005, the unmanned Huygens probe launched by the Cassini mission descended onto Titan’s surface. Recent studies from the Huygens probe suggest that there is hydrogen and acetylene on the surface of Titan, which could serve as nutrients for methanogens even in cold environments, and therefore the presence of primitive life on the surface of Titan is possible. [2] The chemistry of Titan looks hostile to carbon based life, but back on Earth psychrophiles thrive in extreme cold environments and use methane to produce energy. Either way, the resemblance to an early Earth and the complicated chemical processes on Titan are an excellent source of understanding prebiotic processes. [3]


Life in the Solar System - Europa

Since life in the habitable zone did not yet reveal itself, the search has moved further in the solar system to reach the Jovian planets. While life on the gas giants seems unlikely, the Galileo mission to Jupiter has disclosed that its moons are a whole different topic, and Europa holds the gold medal as far as life is concerned, mainly because liquid water seems to be abundant on this tiny moon. Europa presents itself to be a fascinating world. If there is complex life anywhere else in the solar system, it would be here. The moon is covered by an icy, young crust, almost crater-free, denoting that Europa’s surface is active, and craters must have flattened out by the warmth beneath. [1] The moon has no magnetic field, hence no melted inner core. But there is definitely tidal heat, and therefore geological activity, and interaction with Jupiter’s magnetosphere, revealing that the layer under the thick icy crust might as well be a liquid water sea with warm thermal vents at the bottom of the ocean. [2] On Earth life already thrives in warm thermal vents on the ocean floor. Images of Europa taken by Galileo have also revealed volcanic activity that would generate the chemicals necessary for life.

Europa is the main candidate for complex life forms. As Neil deGrasse Tyson points out enthusiastically, “I want to go ice-fishing on Europa, cut a hole, put a submersible, look around, see if anything swims up to the camera lens and looks at the camera”. [3] But a mission capable of digging through the thick icy crust seems ambitious at the moment. A hydrobot is being built in Austin, Texas - the Deep Phreatic Thermal Explorer (DepthX). [4] If DepthX proves itself successful in exploring Earth’s oceans, it may become a viable solution for a mission to Europa. For now, the Europa Jupiter System Mission seems more realistic, as it would search the surface for evidence of fossilized organisms that have been carried up through the cracks and deposited on the surface. Such a mission would be sufficient to reveal life on this moon. Europa Jupiter System Mission is at the moment only a concept planned to launch around 2020 with an orbiter on board. [5]

Notes
[1] Pappalardo, Robert T., James W. Head, and Ronald Greeley. "The Hidden Ocean of EUROPA." Scientific American Special Edition 13, no. 3 (September 2, 2003): 64-73. Academic Search Premier, EBSCOhost (accessed October 11, 2011), 56.
2 Seeds, Michael. The Solar System. Boston: Brooks/Cole, Cengage Learning, 2011, 594.
3 The Universe: Jupiter, directed by Andrew Nock (2007; The History Channel). DVD.
4 Deep Phreatic Thermal Explorer Project. About the DepthX Project. http://www.frc.ri.cmu.edu/depthx/about.html (Accessed October 11, 2011).
5 Lawler, Andrew. "Is This the Best Place to Find Life in the Solar System?." Discover 30, no. 8 (September 2009): 42-47. Academic Search Premier, EBSCOhost (accessed October 11, 2011), 2.

Life in the Solar System - Mars

The fascination with Mars and its habitability has been going on for centuries. And indeed, Mars holds the greatest life potential of all the other planets, since water seems to have been flowing on its surface in the past. The flyby of Mariner 4 in July 1965 has forever changed the hopes that Mars was inhabited by intelligent beings. Mariner 4 revealed a dry planet with a small mass, while the Viking landers confirmed that there was no sign of life on Mars’ surface. [1] The Martian landscape revealed by probes is a witness of a geological active past. On Earth, plate tectonics was essential in promoting biodiversity and defense against mass extinctions. A geological active Red Planet could have been a good habitat for life. In the same time, the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter has revealed the possibility that salty water could flow on the surface during the Martian summer. Frozen water has been detected in middle to high-latitude regions of the planet. [2]

The Martian surface seems lifeless, static, inhospitable, cold, dry, and desolate. Mars is about half the size of Earth and has lower gravity and pressure. Temperature goes down to 100°C bellow zero every night, and the atmosphere has no oxygen, but it is composed almost entirely of carbon dioxide. Liquid water would freeze and evaporate in the same time on the surface. The Red Planet has lost its magnetic field and atmosphere, and the liquid water disappeared from the surface.  Huge dust storms darken its sky for weeks or months. [3] If life has survived here, it must be hidden below the surface where water may still be liquid.

A recent discovery has revealed that Mars’ atmosphere contains light traces of methane. Methane is abundant on Earth, and 90 to 95 percent of it has biological sources. [4] Since ultraviolet radiation on Mars would destroy the methane, the gas must have been recently produced. Geological activity could also be a source, but methane was discovered in areas where there are no volcanoes. The presence of this gas in Mars’ atmosphere could originate from microorganisms living beneath the surface. [5] However, hard proof evidence may only be available when humans will reach Mars. Until then, scientists rely on the rovers Spirit and Opportunity to discover any traces of life on the neighboring planet. While Spirit has been silent since March 2010, Opportunity is still active. The Mars Science Laboratory, nicknamed Curiosity, launching in November 2011 and scheduled to land in August 2012, has as main mission to search for past and present biological activity.

Notes:
[1] Jones, Barrie William. The Search for Life Continued. Chichester: Praxis Publishing, 2008, 78.
2 Webster, Guy, Cole, Steve, Stolte, Daniel. NASA Spacecraft Data Suggest Water Flowing on Mars. NASA, Aug.4, 2011. http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/MRO/news/mro20110804.html (accessed October 11, 2011), 1.
3 Webster, Guy, Cole, Steve, Stolte, Daniel. NASA Spacecraft Data Suggest Water Flowing on Mars. NASA, Aug.4, 2011. http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/MRO/news/mro20110804.html (accessed October 11, 2011), 79.
4 Atreya, Sushil K. "The Mystery of Methane on Mars & Titan. (Cover story)." Scientific American 296, no. 5 (May 2007): 42-51. Academic Search Premier, EBSCOhost (accessed October 11, 2011), 42.
5 Seeds, Michael. The Solar System. Boston: Brooks/Cole, Cengage Learning, 2011, 594.

Tuesday, November 1, 2011

Life in the Solar System - Overview

For millennia, people looked at the sky and wondered about its mysteries. Observing celestial phenomena is a constant that unifies humanity throughout space and time. People followed the movements of the planets and the perpetual change of the constellations. They learned to read their changing patterns, and used them for navigation, agriculture, and warfare. The human hunger for exploration developed further, and man reached the surface of the moon. The search for life elsewhere sprung from a sudden cosmic loneliness that humanity experienced, and hence the question “are we alone?” From looking at the sky to probing other planets with robots, humanity is trying to decipher one of the biggest mysteries known to man. Taking into account the vastness of the universe, searching for life in the neighborhood would be the first step. But where in the solar system should explorers search for life, and what exactly to look for? To gain insight into where and how life could have happened, exploration begins with the only known example: life on Earth. Since Earth seems to be unique, life appears to be sparse. However, life on Earth is abundant and present in extreme environments, therefore it could have developed everywhere else in the universe. This paper provides an overview of the origins of life on Earth and its success in extreme environments as a possible suggestion that life could have developed elsewhere in the solar system, as well as a short research of plausible life on Mars, Europa, Titan and Enceladus.

Life on Earth started four billion years ago, as soon as the conditions on the planet became slightly favorable to ignite the spark of life. Favorable conditions allowed life to become firmly rooted in less than half a billion years. [1] To figure out how this happened and how did non-living matter turn into life, biologists imagined the process of evolution in reverse. Reversing evolution concluded that life on Earth started in simple forms, such as carbon-chained molecules capable of copying themselves. [2] These organisms did not have any bones or shell that could have been fossilized and preserved, and the evidence of their existence is scarce. However, ancient rocks dating over three billion years ago have revealed stromatolites, fossilized colonies of these single cell organisms. Life was thriving in oceans just a billion years after its beginnings. [3]

But what exactly is life? While there is no clear definition, one way of referring to life is by what living organisms do. Life is the process of extracting energy from the surrounding environment in order to maintain and reproduce an organism. [4] All life forms on Earth are carbon based and use water as a solvent. The cell is the basic unit of all living, the ambience in which the processes of life occur. Water is essential for the cell’s proper functioning. Liquid water acts as a solvent for various substances, enabling their transportation inside and between the cells, and it is an active participant in biochemical reactions. [5] Carbon is the best element for formic complex molecules. About all life’s biochemicals are compounds of carbon. Carbon in composition with other elements forms proteins, which have structural, transport, storage, and catalytic functions. The essence of protein synthesis is the RNA and DNA, complex organic compounds playing a role in the process by which organisms reproduce themselves. [6]  

Life on Earth has also developed in extreme conditions. Hyperthermophiles live at high temperatures, between 80–121°C, in the high pressure environment of the ocean floor. Psychrophiles live in low temperatures of about -18°C in the deep oceans, glaciers, polar ice and snowfields. Halophiles live in salinities from 15 to 37.5 percent, alkalophiles live in the alkaline environment of soda lakes and chalky soils, and acidophiles are happy in environments with a pH close to that of vinegar. Some extremophiles can even live in level of radiation lethal to other species. [7] All these organisms are proof that life occurs wherever carbon and liquid water exist.

Having such a successful recipe for life on this planet, the search for life in the cosmic neighborhood starts with looking for the same ingredients: carbon compounds and liquid water. Potential habitats should be abundant in water and carbon, as well as other elements necessary in organic compounds, such as nitrogen. For the water to stay in liquid form, pressure should not be less than 610Pa. Temperature is also crucial: carbon based life can develop in environments with a temperature up to 160°C and down to several tens of degrees bellow 0°C. Habitats can exist either at the surface or below. [8] All these conditions create the so-called habitable zones.

The habitable zone is the range of distances from a star within which water occupies large territories and remains in liquid form on the surface of a planet. [9] It is however not enough for a planet to be in the habitable zone to develop life. Volatiles are needed to form an atmosphere. The planet has to have sufficient mass so that the atmosphere could provide pressure for water to stay liquid; it has to be geologically active; its atmosphere should not leak into space. [10] While Earth has been in the habitable zone throughout its history, Venus has lost its place, and Mars is at the outer boundary.

Water is an abundant substance in the solar system, whether in gaseous or solid form. However life requires liquid water. NASA's Mars Global Surveyor has revealed that some crater walls and hillsides on Mars seem to have formed recently, and liquid water below the surface could have burst out and created the landscape before evaporating. [11] Below surface liquid water is likely to be present also in the outer solar system. Ganymede and Callisto might have oceans trapped between two layers of ice, while Europa is believed to have oceans bellow its ice crust. [12] There seems to be liquid water in the solar system.

The key ingredients essential for life are nutrients and other elements needed for metabolism and reproduction, energy sources (sunlight, chemical reactions, internal heat), liquid water (or other liquid), catalysts such as enzyme proteins, and a stable environment. But life could exist beyond the classical habitable zone. Other habitats could be favorable for different life forms that would revolve around a different element than carbon. Some science fiction stories feature silicon-based life. Silicon belongs to the Group IV of the Periodic Table, together with carbon, and shares many characteristics: both have valence of four, bond to oxygen, form long chains (polymers), alternating with oxygen. However, carbon oxidizes into a gas (carbon dioxide), while silicon into a solid (silicon dioxide). Unlike carbon, silicon does not form many compounds that have handedness, and therefore it would be difficult for such a life form to achieve the functions that carbon-based enzymes perform. The chemistries of life do not seem possible in silicon. [13]

However, arsenic-based life forms have been discovered on Earth: the bacterium GFAJ-1 uses arsenic in its chemical building blocks. Marine algae were found that form organic molecules by incorporating arsenic. [14] Life obviously thrives in environments previously thought to be too harsh, and there is more than one chemical solution to the existence of life. Chlorine and sulfur, as well as nitrogen and phosphorus are also possible replacements for carbon. [15] Since carbon based life has proved to be successful, the search for life must start in the areas where such life forms may be possible. Mars is a candidate.